Our wildest imagination: violence, narrative, and sympathetic identification

Abstract

At this polarizing moment in American politics identifying with the experiences of others feels especially difficult, but it is vital for sharing a world in common. Scholars in a variety of disciplines have argued that narratives, and especially literary ones, can help us cultivate this capacity by soliciting sympathetic identification with particular characters. In doing so, narratives can help us to be more ethically and political responsive to other human beings. This is a limited view of the potential for narratives to solicit sympathetic identification, and it prevents us from identifying and grappling with our resistances to identifying with others. In this article I propose a more expansive view – inspired by Elizabeth Costello, a character in JM Coetzee’s novel of the same name – that there are no bounds to our capacities for sympathetic identification. Through critical readings of Waiting for the Barbarians and Animal Farm I explore the possibility that we might identify with people who cause others to suffer, and perhaps even with animals too. Both sorts of identification engender fierce resistance. Identifying with those who cause suffering demands that we grapple with our own capacities for cruelty and violence. Identifying with animals demands that we confront what is animal in ourselves – the perilous instincts that, unmoderated, incline us to aggression. Acknowledging and working through – without rejecting or disavowing – our capacities for cruelty and our animal instincts is necessary for the practices of sympathetic identification upon which sharing a world depends.

Publisher

Taylor & Francis

Publication Date

1-28-2019

Publication Title

Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy

Department

Politics

Document Type

Article

DOI

https://dx.doi.org/10.1080/13698230.2019.1565702

Notes

Special Issue: Political Violence and the Imagination, edited by Mihaela Mihai and Mathias Thaler.

Keywords

Coetzee, Orwell, Narrative, Posthumanism, Sympathetic identification, Violence

Language

English

Format

text

Link to Full Text

Share

COinS